Eteraz.org ||


Help us raise $30,000 to purchase 1000 copies of the Muhammad Asad Translation and Commentary of The Quran to be donated to Western mosques and prisons. This work resolves many of the errors and oversights of the Saudi sponsored translations, one example being women's rights.
Permalink

More Jamal Miftah & More Failure of American Muslim Organizations


By Ali Eteraz
Posted on Sat Feb 17, 2007 at 05:14:28 AM EST
Tags: miftah (all tags)

By the end of this post you'll see that yet another one of my predictions has come true. 


Back in November I did a bunch of pieces on Jamal Miftah from Tulsa, Oklahoma, who got kicked out of his mosque for writing an editorial in the local paper. Here is a link to all the stories in reverse chronological order, including my interview of him.

Now, Hot Air TV, belonging to conservative blogger Michelle Malkin, went to Tulsa and did another story on Miftah. It's a video.

The video paints Miftah as the victim (ok, fine) and the Islamic Center as the "radical Islamists" (which is unfair).

However, something Miftah has said really disturbed me. If you go to the middle of the video there is a clip of him from Fox News where he says about the Islamic Center:

It was not an express threat. But it is an implied message to the others that he is anti-Islamic: you kill him you go to heaven.

Ok. I think he's gone overboard with that. It is very unlikely that any one at that mosque was encouraging killing Miftah and there is probably a lawsuit for libel available against him.  Whatever remnants of support I have for Miftah are gone.

However, it occurred to me in reviewing this entire file that this mess could have been averted. It should have been averted.

At one point -- I believe upon writing the last post on the subject -- I emailed the head of MPAC and asked my cousin to email the head of ISNA. To MPAC I said in pertinent parts the following:

Dear Mr. Al-Maryati,

I emailed you yesterday to encourage you to get involved in the Jamal Miftah fiasco in Oklahoma.

I am emailing you again because I think there is a far bigger fiasco likely to occur unless some Muslim group gets involved.

I don't think ISNA is going to. They are going to let the mosque deal with at the local level. CAIR is not an honest broker in this situation because they have board members on the mosque.

What are you waiting for? For an FBI investigation which you will then have to spin in some positive way?

*

Now that no one is listening to him it is possible he might go public.

*

It's only a matter of time before the Islamophobes get on top of this. My site gets thousands of readers a weak. They are not all Muslim. Do the math.

You need to go to the IST.

*

You need to do this because if you don't, people who hate Muslims will. If I don't hear back from you in 3 days I am going public with this. That's not a threat. It's a call to action.

ISNA said they weren't going to get involved. MPAC didn't do anything. I even emailed their communications director.

Ultimately I did not go public with it. However, now I can because the Muslim organizations didn't do jack and Miftah went public -- of course he went public, by the way, because I'm sure Fox had a nice paycheck for him. Now he's saying stuff like "you kill him you go to heaven." And the Islamophobes are all over it. And the Muslim organizations, rather than stemming the bleeding at the very beginning, let it allllllll fall down.

Yet another prediction by me, made, ignored by Muslims, and now Muslims pay the price.

This is absurd.

There is a very simple lesson here: this world is not a place where Muslim groups with organizational skill and money can let "local issues" rest "with the local community, brother." [That was essentially how ISNA blew off the person I delegated to get in touch with them].

How many times do I have to say it? When it comes to a Muslim in the news, there is no more local. Everything is global. Everytime Miftah says "you kill him you go to heaven" the impact is global.

With a Muslim involved there is no such thing as local.

With a Muslim involved there is no such thing as local.

With a Muslim involved there is no such thing as local.

Please, someone, anyone, get this through your heads.

< Watch Official Eteraz Commercial | Eteraz.Org: Muhammad Asad Quran Distribution Project >

Login

Make a new account

Username:
Password:

Tags: miftah (all tags)
Display: Sort:

You are 1000% dead-on(none / 0) (#1)
by Isis13 on Sat Feb 17, 2007 at 10:14:00 AM EST

You have spoken truth.  The recent example of the 17-year old Bosnian refugee who went on a spree killing (yes, that is a technical, foresenic, criminal pathology for what he did)  is being made to look like a global-jihad terror tactic, which is trivializing the meaning of "terrorism" and being used to condemn the entire the American Muslim community by some rightwing entities.  Surely, Miftah's words will be used to further tarnish the reputation of American Muslims further in various media outlets. 

 



A case history that makes your point.(none / 0) (#2)
by Isis13 on Sat Feb 17, 2007 at 10:59:45 AM EST

Ali:

I wanted to share you my experience on a conservative forum that makes your point.

It is related to the thread on this forum that was reviewing the Sulejman Talovic story.  Before I had a chance to comment, the commentary on Bosnian Muslims had devolved to the point several conservative posters were saying the US had backed the wrong side of the war -- and perhaps America would be better served if Clinton had let Milosevic complete his "ethnic cleaning" of the Muslims.

Unlike other members on that Forum, I utilize Eteraz.org for information related to the Muslim community. Here, I located Sahama's posts, which contained a letter of sympathy from a Bosnian Muslim community leader and a call for a donation fund to the victim's families.

I prompty posted this information, with a request to the members of my group to consider donating instead of calling for retaliation.  The thread's tenor changed promptly after that information was presented.  While there is no way to change the hearts of individuals intent on hating Muslims no matter what, the display of sympathy and charity by Muslims toward non-Muslims diffused a spiraling situation and perhaps prevented the creation of one more JAFI.

This is a heartbreaking situation.  It is difficult for me to understand how reasonable people, with whom I agree on other matters of political/national/international importance can simply hate others based on a religion about which they have utterly no understanding. The only thing that I can offer is that it is not limited to Muslims, as can be noted if you read the post on Mitt Romney and his Mormon faith.  

I can only hope that your community eventually appreciates the wisdom of your approach. 

Isis 

<h2>
</h2>

 



[ Parent ]





Display: Sort: